Page 30 - RD_2015_12
P. 30

Issue 38 ran the photo (left) on the
                                                                                inside back cover. It is an example of
                                                                                confusion in identification caused by a
                                                                                theatre make-over. Donated to CATHS
                                                                                as a photo of the Grand Coburg, the
                                                                                accuracy of this claim was later
                                                                                queried when a different photo of the
                                                                                Grand (from someone who would
                                                                                know) was received.
                                                                                   CATHS member Steve Walsh of
                                                                                the Rex Charlton assessed that the
                                                                                picture was a Hoyts house. Because of
                                                                                the shallow rake of the balcony Steve
                                                                                suggested that it was a theatre that did
                                                                                not have an lounge foyer beneath the
                                                                                balcony. If it wasn’t the Grand, then
                                                                                he nominated the Waratah Ascot Vale.
                                                                                   That was a good try Steve, but we
                                                                                had misled you. A closer look for
                                                                                comparative photos showed that it was
                                                                                in fact the Grand prior to a 1940
                                                                                update, also by Cowper, Appleford
                                                                                and Murphy. The Waratah shared the
                                                                                same body shape, but the clincher was
                                                                                the match up of the simple ceiling
                                                                                patterns with the Grand before and
                                                                                after the changes. The re-vamped
                                                                                interior is shown below.






















































          30  2003 CINEMARECORD
   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32